Reed, Malone, Boswell

Samuel Johnson-George Steevens-Isaac Reed V (1803, "First Variorum")

The largest edition of Shakespeare to date, v1803 occupied the first three volumes with prefatory materials before getting to the plays in volume 4.  The meticulous fulsomeness was counterbalanced by a desire to present more Shakespeare and less scaffolding.


v1803v1  v1803v2  v1803v3 

v1803v4  v1803v5  v1803v6 

v1803v7 v1803v8 

v1803v9  v1803v10  

Samuel Johnson-George Steevens-Isaac Reed VI (1813, "Second Variorum")

Edmond Malone-James Boswell the Younger (1821, "Third Variorum")

 James Boswell the Younger conceived of the edition as a way to validate Malone and defend him from what he considered to be Steevens's unjust criticism of his hero.


1821v1 1821v2 1821v3 1821v4 1821v5 1821v6 1821v7 1821v8 1821v9 1821v10 1821v11 1821v12 1821v13 1821v14 1821v15 1821v16 1821v17 1821v18 1821v19 1821v20 1821v21 

Boydell, Chalmers, Singer

The Boydell Shakespeare (1791-1805)

 

Josiah Boydell conceived an edition of Shakespeare based on those of Steevens and Reed, illustrated by prints based on episodes in the plays in order to encourage historical painting in England.  A gallery was established as well, and the edition was produced between 1791-1805. Arguably, this initiated the movement away from the encyclopedic variorum text in favor of an illustrated, popular Shakespeare, which accorded well with nineteenth-century taste.


Images


Wiki on Boydell


William D. Moffat  on Boydell in Shakesperiana (1887)

Alexander Chalmers (1805)

Chalmers presented the v1803 virtually entire, sans commentary, which some saw as a welcome development.


CHAv1  CHAv2  CHAv3 CHAv4  CHAv5  CHAv6 CHAv7 CHAv8  CHAv9 CHAv10


Chalmers's DNB entry

Samuel Weller Singer (1826, 1856)

 

Singer’s 1826 multivolume edition of the plays was created in reaction to the line of Variorum editions of Johnson, Steevens, Reed, and Boswell (1773-1821) with their sometimes prodigious commentary, with illustrations and relatively few commentary notes. His second edition (1856) reflects three subsequent decades of Shakespeare scholarship, as well as the controversies created by the Collier forgeries in the Perkins Folio. It is almost always fully collated by contemporary Shakespeare editors. The 1856 ed. was greatly improved by the help of Knight and Collier, handsomely printed, and well respected. Singer was an autodidact like many Shakespeareans. Though he was somewhat disdainful of his 18th. c. predecessors, he relies on them heavily for commentary, most often uncredited.


SING1v1 SING1v2 SING1v3 SING1v4 SING1v5 SING1v6 SING1v7 SING1v8  SING1v9 SING1v10 


SING2v1 SING2v2 SING2v3 SING2v4 SING2v5 SING2v6 SING2v7 SING2v8 SING2v9 SING2v10  


The Text of Shakespeare Vindicated (1853)


Singer's DNB entry.

Valpy, Knight, Collier

Abraham John Valpy (1832-34)

Valpy (1787-1854) was a scholar, classicist, and foremost a printer, bringing out scholarly and popular editions of modern and ancient writers His Shakespeare featured the sumptuous illustrations of Boydell accompanying the text as edited by Malone, with a minimum of commentary.


VALPYv1  VALPYv2  VALPYv3  VALPYv4  VALPYv5  VALPYv6  

VALPYv7 VALPYv8

VALPYv9  VALPYv10  VALPYv11 VALPYv12 VALPYv13 

VALPYv14 VALPYv15


Valpy's DNB entry from 1900

Charles S. Knight (1841)

 Knight was a publishing polymath. He produced four fine editions of Shakespeare along with a biography and weighed in on the Collier controversy. He was a journalist, published The English Cyclopedia (vol1, vol2, vol3) and a history of England, and superintended the publications of the Society for the Diffusion of Useful Knowledge. This first edition was second in line, after Samuel Weller Singer’s 1826 Shakespeare, of the major post-Variorum editions. Like Singer, he eschwed the extensive scholarly commentary of the Enlightenment editors, aiming for a general, even popular audience. The illustrations, of course, were the selling point, and are marvelously done.


His palomar.edu entry


KNT1v1  KNT1v2  KNT1v3  KNT1v4  KNT1v5  KNT1v6  KNT1v7


Studies of Shakspere (1849)



John Payne Collier (1842-44; 1878)

Collier chose criminality because he believed he would not be taken seriously on his own merits, even though it was well known that he had been friends with Keats, his father had entertained Wordsworth and other luminaries at the family home, and he had tutored Singer and Knight to some extent in perfectly legitimate editorial method. Nevertheless, entrusted with valuable mss. and books, he forged names and signatures and commentary in an unconvincing secretary hand.  His greatest crime was his interpolation of neo-seventeenth-century marginalia in the "Perkins Folio," a copy of F2, ruining it forever.  He was discovered and excoriated.  Oddly, the emendations he forged were good and tenable conjectures, and would have been acceptable in book form or as part of an edition under his own name, without the folderol travesty of "Tho. Perkins." He published four Shakespeare collections and the first is usually the one that scholars consult. Because his chicanery was so intertwined with his second and third editions,  scholars often quote them because, like it or not, they are part of the textual history of the plays. Some later scholars adapted those emendations in their published editions. The fourth edition (1878) was advertised as a clean break from the past, though he sometimes defends "Perkins folio" materials.


1842-44


COL1v1  COL1v2  COL1v3  COL1v4  COL1v5  COL1v6  COL1v7  COL1v8


1853


COL2


1858


COL3v1  COL3v2  COL3v3  COL3v4  COL3v5  COL3v6



1878


COL4v1  COL4v2  COL4v3  COL4v4  COL4v5  COL4v6  COL4v7  COL4v8


Univeristy of Delaware page on the Collier Controversy


Terry Gray's page on Collier


Reasons for a New Edition (1842)


Notes and Emendations to the Text of Shakespeare's Plays from Early Manuscript Corrections in a Copy of the Folio, 1632 (1853)

Verplanck, Delius, Keightley

Gulian C. Verplanck (1847)

Nicolaus Delius (1854-60)

 

DELv1 DELv2 DELv3 DELv4 DELv5 DELv6 DELv7


Leopold Edition (1883): Frederick Furnivall's English version of Delius's text. 


Bekannt wurde Delius durch seine Shakespeare-Ausgabe, die er zwischen 1854 und 1860 veröffentlichte. Dies verschaffte ihm, der seit 1855 eine Doppelprofessur für Französisch und Englisch hatte, bis 1880 einen Lehrstuhl für Anglistik, den ersten in Deutschland überhaupt. Delius war Mitbegründer und lange Zeit Vorsitzender der Deutschen Shakespeare-Gesellschaftund verfasste eine Vielzahl von Aufsätzen, Abhandlungen und Übersetzungen zu diesem Themenfeld. Seine wertvolle Shakespearesammlung vermachte er der Stadtbibliothek Bremen


Nikolaus Delius became well known for his edition of Shakespeare’s works between 1854 and 1860. Since 1855 Delius held a chair for combined French-English studies but because of this edition he was given a chair in English studies, the first ever to be given in Germany. He held the chair up to 1880. Delius was a co-founder and for years to come chairman of the Deutschen Shakespeare-Gesellschaft (German Shakespeare Society). He was the author of a multitude of articles, papers, and translations regarding Shakespeare. He left his valuable Shakespeare collection to the Bremen public library 

Thomas Keightley (1864)

 

Keightley edited Milton as well as Shakespeare, but was probably better known for his History of Greece (1848) and The Fairy Mythology (1828), both of which went through many subsequent editions. He was not conservative with Shakespeare’s text, emending freely, often judiciously, and tends to be quoted occasionally by Variorum editors 


KTLYv1  KTLYv2  KTLYv3  KTLYv4  KTLYv5  KTLYv6


The Shakespeare Expositor (1867)

Halliwell, Hudson, Dyce

James Orchard Halliwell-Phillipps (1864)

Halliwell-Phillipps (known by his first surname for most of his life) was a Shakespeare polymath and well-regarded editor and biographer to most.  The dark side: some theft, book mutilation, and other chicanery.  He had an enormous collection of antiquarian material that Henry Clay Folger acquired from a third party, which now resides at the Folger Shakespeare Library.


HALv1  HALv2  HALv3  HALv4  HALv5  HALv6  HALv7  HALv8  HALv9  HALv10  HALv11  HALv12  HALv13  HALv14  HALv15  HALv16


  

Guardian article on Halliwell-Phillipps

Henry N. Hudson (1851, 1891)

 Hudson created the first significant American edition of Shakespeare (1851-56) after that of G.C. Verplanck (1847), with others to follow, most notably the Hudson School Shakespeare (1871-73) and the magisterial final edition (1881). Some scholars consider him invaluable in the line of editors and commentators. 


1857


HUD1v1  HUD1v2  HUD1v3  HUD1v4  HUD1v5  HUD1v6  HUD1v7  HUD1v8  HUD1v9  HUD1v10  HUD1v11  


1881


 vol1  vol2  vol3  vol4  vol5  vol6  vol7  vol8  vol9  vol10  vol11  vol12 


Alexander Dyce

Dyce was a Johnsonian polymath, with three editions of Shakespeare (1857; 1864-67; 1875-76), one of Skelton, Middleton, an anthology of women poets, Shirley, Will Kempe, Collins, Beaumont and Fletcher, Marlowe, and more.  He was friends with Collier but did not spare him in his analysis of the Perkins folio or other forgeries.


DYCE1v1  DYCE1v2  DYCE1v3  DYCEv14  DYCE1v5  DYCE1v6  


DYCE2v1  DYCE2v2  DYCE2v3  DYCE2v4  DYCE2v5  DYCE2v6  DYCE2v7  DYCE2v8  DYCE2v9    

Staunton, White, Rolfe

Howard Staunton

Staunton was much better known as a chess player than a Shakespearean, but enjoyed editing so much that he took it up as a kind of vocation.


STAUv1  (1858)  STAUv2 (1859)  STAUv3 (1860)

Richard Grant White

Known as Grant White, just as John Dover Wilson was known as Dover Wilson and C.F. Tucker Brooke preferred to omit his praenomen, he was probably the first truly original American editor.  


(1857-66--some vols. are the 1888 rpt. of this ed.)


WH1v1  WH1v2  WH1v3  WH1v4  WH1v5  WH1v6  WH1v7  WH1v8  WH1v9  WH1v10  WH1v11  WH1v12  



1883 Riverside ed.


WH2v1  WH2v2  WH2v3 WH2v4  WH2v5  WH2v6  


Studies in Shakespeare (1886)


Terry Gray's Grant White page

William J. Rolfe

Rolfe was an educator who spent most of his career in Boston and environs.  It is said that George Lyman Kittredge used his editions of the plays in his courses at Harvard. He helped with the revision of George L. Craik's The English of Shakespeare (1872), focusing on JC.  He edited Tennyson, Milton, Ovid, and Vergil.


"The Friendly Shakespeare," 40 vols.  (1870-1911)


Ado  Ant.   AWW   AYL  Cor.  Cym.  Err.  1H4   2H4   H5  1H6  2H6  3H6  Ham.  H8  JC   Jn.  LLL


Lr.  Mac.  MM  MND  MV  MWW  Oth.  Per.   Poems


R2  R3  Rom.  Shr.  Son  TGV  Tim.  Tit.  Tmp.  TN   TNK   Tro.   WT  


Life of Shakespeare (1904)

The Globe Shakespeare

Globe tp, 1864

The Fabulous Globe

The Globe was immensely popular and affordable. The original print run of 50,000 was thought to be a disastrous exercise in publishing overconfidence. As it happens, that was not nearly enough to satisfy demand, and its sales reached 100, 000 copies. Its line-numbers and act and scene divisions are still used for Norton and Riverside editions. It was the first truly critical edition. Each play for the first time was completely collated by the earliest editions of the the given work generally known.  


Its final editors, William George Clark (1823-78) and William Aldis Wright (1831-1914) are generally credited with standardizing the spelling of Shakespeare's name as is seen now, rather than the many forms in early editions according to his signatures or interpretations of them. 


Open Source Shakespeare page on the Globe.


The complete Globe text

Wliiam George Clark

Clark and Wright

Both Clark (pictured) and Wright reached Cambridge from humble origins, the former the son of a farmer and the latter the son of a Baptist minister. Wright's adhered to his family's faith, so his religious nonconformity  prevented him becoming a fellow at Trinity College until 1878, even though he was the college librarian.  Clark's Anglicanism meant he could reach this status by the age of 23 in 1852.  It is alleged that the two men were antipodal in personality, Clark gregarious and pleasant, Wright a dour loner. 


Trinity College bio of Wright


Christopher Decker on the Clark and Wright collaborations

William Aldis Wright, NPG

Similarities

Wright (pictured) and Clark bore a resemblance to one another. Neither married, seeing their profession as a vocation. Each read several languages and produced scholarship on ancient texts, Clark on Greek antiquity, Wright on the Bible. They were both self-taught textual scholars and encouraged each other's ideas for innovation, such as standardized act, scene, and line-numbers, which greatly aided scholarship and reference work. 



 Open Source Shakespeare site on Clark and Wright 

Clark, Glover, Wright

Clark, Glover, and Wright: First Cambridge (1865)

In tandem, GLO and CAM1 were arguably the first edition in the modern dual incarnation of a one-volume and multivolume form.  William George Clark (pictured) and William Aldis Wright were the editors for the Globe and the last eight volumes of CAM1, Clark with John Glover (1823-84) on the first. Glover was Librarian at Trinity College, Cambridge.  When Glover left Cambridge to be Vicar of Brading, Isle of Wight in 1862, Wright took over his position with the university and with Clark on the Globe. 


CAM1v1  CAM1v2  CAM1v3  CAM1v4  CAM1v5  CAM1v6  CAM1v7  CAM1v8

 CAM!v9

William Aldis Wright, by Walter William Ouless

Second Cambridge (1891), Clarendon Press Series

William Aldis Wright (pictured) prepared this edition entirely by himself. 


CAM2v1  CAM2v2  CAM2v3  CAM2v4  CAM2v5  CAM2v6  CAM2v7  CAM2v8  CAM2v9



Clarendon Press Series, First Oxford

William Aldis Wright (NPG)

Clarendon Press Series Shakespeare (1869-90)

William Aldis Wright (pictued) assumed complete control of this series on the retirement of Clark.  These are handsome single editions that reflect the best of the Cambridge work. 


 CLN1AYL CLN1COR CLN1H8 CLN11H4 CLNHAM CLN1JC CLN1JN CLN1LR  CLN1H5 CLN1MAC CLN1MV CLN1MND CLN1ADO CLN1TN  CLNR3 CLNTMP CLNR2 CLNNOTES1 CLNNOTES2  

First Oxford (1891)

W. J. Craig (1843-1906) taught at the University College of Wales, Aberystwyth, and Trinity College, Dublin. He preferred private tutoring in London, for which he was highly esteemed. One of his pupils was the future great Japanese novelist Natsume Soseki.  This helped add to Shakespeare's reputation and popularity in Japan, influencing artists such as Akira Kurosawa, the film director known for his adaptations of Mac (Throne of Blood) and Lr. (Ran).  


Craig's major project was a glossary of Shakespeare that he never finished. Yet his ed. (1891) was his legacy, serving as Oxford's Shakespeare for almost a century. R . B. McKerrow had planned an old-spelling complete works, even writing a Prolegomenon laying out his principles (1938), but death intervened. 



OXF1

Pickering, Irving-Marshall

William Pickering (1825)

Although there is some debate about the matter, Pickering (1796-1854) is often credited with developing the first dyed cloth binding on boards with the title printed on the spine. He was apprenticed to a printer in 1810 and set up his own shingle in 1820.  He was an impresario and a raconteur, spending money freely. He enjoyed the craft of printing and bookbinding, but not the business end of it. Pickering specialized in miniature books, and his 1825 Shakespere was the smallest edition (9 x 5 cm) known up to that time. It could be said that he invented the modern pocket book. The text is said to follow v1778 or v1785.


PICKv1  PICKv2  PICKv3  PICKv4   PICKv5  PICKv6  PICKv7   PICKv8  PICKv9   PICKpoetry(1832)


(Illustration: William Pickering and Charles Whittingham in the summer house at Chiswick)

Henry Irving and Frank Marshall (1889-90)

There had been no performance-oriented Shakespeare since Bell's edition of 1773, which printed promptbooks from Drury Lane. Irving and Marshall's edition of 1889-90 changed that. Of humble and obscure origin, Irving (born John Henry Brodribb in 1838) was self-educated, flamboyant, and wonderfuly entertaining as an actor in Shakespeare and popular repertory. He took over the management of the Lyceum Theatre in the West End in 1878.  The year was momentous because he began his professional partnership with Ellen Terry (1847-1928). They collaborated on a number of magnificent Shakespeare productions, including a MV that ran for 260 nights, with Terry as Portia and Irving as Shylock. 


Irving was especially keen on making his edition for actors, with cues and added stage-directions. Marshall and many other great scholars wrote the other notes and the introductions. Each volume is lavishly illustrated.


IRVv1  IRVv2  IRVv3  IRV4  IRVv5  IRVv6  IRVv7  IRVv8  


(Terry and Irving in an adaptation of Goldsmith's The Vicar of Wakefield.  They were fortunate to have each other, and they knew it.)